KUMHO TIRE CO., LTD., et al. v. CARMICHAEL et al.

Justice Scalia, with whom Justice O’Connor and Justice Thomas join, concurring.

I join the opinion of the Court, which makes clear that the discretion it endorses–trial-court discretion in choosing the manner of testing expert reliability–is not discretion to abandon the gatekeeping function. I think it worth adding that it is not discretion to perform the function inadequately. Rather, it is discretion to choose among reasonable means of excluding expertise that is fausse and science that is junky. Though, as the Court makes clear today, the Daubert factors are not holy writ, in a particular case the failure to apply one or another of them may be unreasonable, and hence an abuse of discretion. Next Page ->


Expert Witness Directory  Copyright 2003 Exify, LLC All Rights Reserved  Terms of Use